Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Why not?

This is Lucy today.

Lucy is not a sob story. At three years old she has been removed from a bad situation with the promise that she will live out the rest of her long life with plenty of food, love, treats, cuddles and soft cushions. Lucy will never be forced to carry another litter of puppies, destined to be sent out into the world to the highest bidder with little thought as to their ultimate fate. Best Friends made that promise to Lucy when they transported her to a shelter in Chicago, One Tail at a Time made that promise to Lucy when they pulled her into their program, as her foster home I made that promise to Lucy and very soon the perfect adoptive home will come along and make that promise to Lucy. Lucy has a team on her side.

But Lucy is still just one dog among thousands. As she trotted along at my side this evening - almost perfectly leash trained in just a week - a man walked up behind us. He paused as he passed.

"She have babies?"

"Why not?"

I could have cried. I could have hit him. I spluttered and stammered and called out no, you shouldn't breed, you should adopt, she's escaped a puppy mill and will never have babies again. Ultimately, the only thing he wanted to hear was whether or not he could get a puppy from her. After the negative he just shrugged his shoulders and walked away. I wish there was a way in that 5 second conversation to share everything I've seen in shelters, everything I've read and learned and heard. I wish I spoke good enough Spanish to have reached out in his own language and explained at least a small part of what I know.

Next week I'll add a bi-lingual pamphlet to my walking supplies and I'll hand it out to every kid who asks me if Billy is a girl just because they can't see any testicles, to every lady who pulls up in her car to ask if I know anyone who wants to buy a pitbull puppy, to every family with a pregnant chihuahua running round the front yard.

For the sake of every Lucy out there I will have an answer to the question, "Why not?"

  • Because every hour in the US, more that 2,000 dogs and 3,500 cats are born compared to 415 humans.
  • Because more than 20% of the dogs in shelters are purebred.
  • Because only one in every 10 puppies finds a permanent home.
  • Because in 6 years one female dog and her offspring can be the source of 67,000 puppies.
  • Because 11,000 animals die in American shelters EVERY DAY.
  • Because ultimately, the only result of indiscriminately breeding dogs in backyards or commercial mills is this


  1. I get the same way, I wish I could explain to people why. Usually my why - Havi's first year of life was stolen from her. And she is a lucky one.

  2. Heidi was also used by a BYB and had at least two litters of puppies. We've been asked a few times if we would breed Melanie or Heidi and it never ceases to tick me off. Our dogs are the lucky ones.

  3. We get the same thing-- all of our female fosters -- three now -- have been mommas, and without fail, we get questions about whether they have puppies. I also wish I had a smart way to respond. I end up just getting kind upset and quietly saying "no." Most of those people don't want to engage in conversation, and none of them want to be lectured. I know that the best way to change somebody's mind is to meet them where they are -- giving them a bunch of statistics about pet overpopulation will probably not work. But what's the right way? Maybe we should get some of our smart dog rescue bloggers together to brainstorm, and collectively come up with a small handout to carry on walks and to events. Thoughts?


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...